Semenya v Belair Insurance Company Inc., 2026 ONLAT 25-014626/AABS

A collision causing minimal vehicle damage can still have life-changing consequences. In this case, Foisy & Associates represented a client whose insurer disputed that her accident-related mental and behavioural impairments met the threshold for catastrophic impairment.

Our client had pre-existing medical conditions and was injured in a rear-end collision. Belair Insurance argued that the accident had not caused her claimed catastrophic impairments and that her functional limitations were moderate rather than marked.

Following a five-day hearing, the Licence Appeal Tribunal found our client catastrophically impaired under criterion 8 of the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule. It found marked impairment across all four functional domains: activities of daily living; social functioning; concentration, persistence, and pace; and adaptation.

Proving The Difference Between Supported Functioning and Independence

A central issue in this case was whether our client’s ability to perform certain activities demonstrated independence. Our firm presented evidence from her daughter, treating rehabilitation professionals, and catastrophic impairment assessors showing how extensively she depends on others.

The Tribunal accepted that reminders, structured routines, safety devices, and ongoing assistance created the appearance of independence. Her ability to complete some tasks with those supports did not establish that she could initiate, sustain, and complete them independently.

The Tribunal found our psychiatric expert’s evidence persuasive. It gave less weight to the insurer’s psychiatric assessor, whose ratings did not adequately account for the evidence of her dependence and functional limitations.

Pre-Existing Conditions Did Not Defeat The Claim

Applying the “but for” causation test, the Tribunal found that the collision was a necessary cause of our client’s impairments. Her pre-existing conditions did not prevent her from establishing accident-related catastrophic impairment.

The catastrophic impairment determination provides access to increased accident benefit coverage for her care and rehabilitation needs, subject to the applicable entitlement requirements. The Tribunal also awarded an additional $5,442.25 toward three disputed treatment plans, plus interest on overdue benefits.

Our firm had previously represented this client successfully in a separate hearing concerning her entitlement to non-earner benefits.

Has Your Insurer Disputed Your Catastrophic Impairment Claim?

Complex accident benefits disputes require careful presentation and a clear understanding of how medical evidence translates into everyday functioning. Contact Foisy & Associates to discuss your claim.

The results described on this page are based on the specific facts and circumstances of each case and do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future matter.

Welcome to Foisy & Associates

What can we help you with?

Welcome to Injury Lawyer Canada!

How can I assist you today?